Comparison of Bem and Fem Methods for the E/meg Problem
نویسندگان
چکیده
The direct electro/magnetoencephalographic (E/MEG) problem consists of simulating the electromagnetic field produced by neuronal sources on the cortex. We compare two different methods for the resolution of this problem, from the point of view of computational complexity and accuracy. First, the finite element method (FEM), based on the discretization of the PDE in the entire head volume. Second, the boundary element method (BEM), discretizing the equivalent integral equations on the surfaces separating volumes with different electrical parameters. We also study the behaviour of BEM and FEM for the sources approaching the discontinuity in conductivity. We conclude that at the current state of investigation, for equivalent meshes, the FEM is significantly faster than BEM and provides similar or better accuracy.
منابع مشابه
Stiffeners Mechanical Effect Analysis by Numerical Coupling
Given any structure, we seek to find the solution of mechanical problem as precisely and efficiently as possible. Within this condition, the BEM is robust and promising development, standing out in the analysis of cases with occurrence of large stress gradients, as in problems of fracture mechanics. Moreover, in BEM the modeling of infinite means is performed naturally, without the use of appro...
متن کاملThe symmetric BEM: bringing in more variables for better accuracy
Electrophysiological modeling of Magnetoand Electro-encephalography (MEG and EEG) rely on accurate forward solvers that relate source activities to sensor measurements. In comparing a Boundary Element (BEM) and a Finite Element Method (FEM) for forward electroencephalography, in our early numerical experiments, we found the FEM to have a better accuracy than the BEM. This triggered a quest to i...
متن کاملComparing FEM-BEM and FEM-DBCI for open-boundary electrostatic field problems
This paper compares the hybrid FEM-BEM and FEM-DBCI methods for the solution of openboundary electrostatic field problems. Both methods couple a differential equation for the interior problem with an integral equation for the exterior one. The comparison shows that FEM-BEM is more accurate than FEM-DBCI but requires more computing time. PACS. 41.20.Cv Electrostatics; Poisson and Laplace equatio...
متن کاملApplication of Boundera Element Method (Bem) to Two-Dimensional Poisson's Eqation
BEM can be used to solve Poisson's equation if the right hand side of the equation is constant because it can easily be transformed to an equivalent Laplace equation. However, if the right hand side is not constant, then such a treatment is impossible and part of the equation can not be transformed over the boundary, hence, the whole domain has to be discretized. Although this takes away impor...
متن کاملCombined BEM/FEM vs. 3DFEM Substrate Resistance Modeling
In the context of substrate resistance modeling a combined BEM/FEM method is compared to a 3DFEM method. The combined BEM/FEM method is applicable in substrate modeling problems which involve layout-dependent doping patterns for which a standalone BEM would not be accurate enough and for which a standalone FEM would be too slow. The method captures local couplings within the doping pattern with...
متن کامل